Boosting Circularly Polarized Luminescence of Organic Conjugated Systems via Twisted Intramolecular Charge Transfer

Realizing a high luminescence dissymmetry factor (glum) is a paramount yet challenging issue in the research field of circularly polarized luminescence (CPL). Here, we reported a novel set of organic conjugated systems with twisted intramolecular charge transfer (TICT) characteristics based on conjugated o-carborane-binaphthyl dyads composing of binaphthyl units as chiral electron donors and o-carborane units as achiral electron acceptors, demonstrating intense CPL with large glum values. Interestingly, single-crystalline o-1 exhibited a high-level brightness and a large glum factor as high as +0.13, whereas single-crystalline o-2 processed a relatively low brightness with a decreased glum value to -0.04. The significant diversity of CPL-active properties was triggered by the selective introduction of o-carborane units onto the binaphthyl units. Benefiting from the large magnetic dipole transition moments in TICT states, the CPL activity of TICT o-carborane-based materials exhibited amplified circular polarization. This study provides an efficient molecular engineering strategy for the rational design and development of highly efficient CPL-active materials.


Introduction
In recent years, organic π-conjugated functional materials [1][2][3], especially chiroptical materials featuring with circularly polarized luminescence (CPL), have attracted growing interest for their wide potential applications in threedimensional (3D) optical displays [4], optical storage and processing systems [5], color-image projection [6], liquid crystal lasers [7], biological probes and signatures [8], security tags [9], light-emitting diodes [10][11][12], and, especially, backlighting liquid crystal displays [13]. Concerning CPLactive materials, one of the major targets is to achieve a large luminescence dissymmetry factor (g lum ), which reflects the level of CPL properties. Generally, g lum = 2ðI L − I R Þ/ðI L + I R Þ, in which I L and I R denote the intensity of left and right circularly polarized light, respectively [14]. Theoretically, g lum is simply approximated by 4jmjμj cos θ/ðjmj 2 + jμj 2 Þ, in which m and μ denote the magnetic and electric transition dipole moments, respectively, and θ denotes the angle between m and μ [15]. High g lum values could only arise from m -allowed and μ-forbidden transitions, while low values are generally induced by m-forbidden and μ-allowed transitions. However, owing to the essential large |μ| and negligible |m| in chiral organic materials, it is generally very challenging to achieve highly efficient CPL activity. The development of a novel organic system featuring with relatively large |m| and depressed jμj would contribute to enhancing CPL with large g lum .
To amplify g lum values, various organic material systems and approaches have been explored by constructing aggregation-induced CPL material systems [16], selfassembly supramolecular material systems [17], Förster resonance energy transfer systems [18,19], or triplet-triplet annihilation upconversion CPL systems [20], etc. Nevertheless, the jg lum j values of the existing organic systems are still quite low and generally fall into the range of 10 -4 to 10 -2 , which hampers largely the further investigation of organic materials for CPL applications [21]. On the other hand, it has been well demonstrated that charge-transfer (CT) organic materials consisting of π-electron-rich donors and π-electron-deficient acceptors are endowed with a forbidden electron dipole transition moment and a relatively large magnetic transition moment [22]. It is surmised that intense CPL with large g lum could thus be achieved for the CT-active materials that are emissive with inherent chirality, which remains yet to be attempted by far.
In this contribution, to verify the above hypothesis, a novel set of organic conjugated systems based on isomeric o-carborane-functionalized binaphthyl (BINOL) dyads with the same (R)-axial chirality have been designed, synthesized, and investigated, in which o-carborane units act as achiral electron acceptors and BINOL units as chiral electron donors. The chemical structures of the resulting o-carborane-binaphthyl dyads, 6,6′-carborane-substituted BINOL (o-1), and 3,3 ′ -carborane-substituted BINOL (o-2), are depicted in Figure 1(a). The dihedral angles of BINOL are completely dependent on the substituents. The electrondeficient o-carborane units are prone to induce molecular charge transfer, leading to a charge-separated state [23,24]. Twisted intramolecular charge transfer (TICT) emissions from o-1 to o-2 were observed, presumably originating from the rotational movement of o-carborane segments. The formation of the TICT state and the emission mechanism [25] are illustrated in Figures 1(b) and 1(c), in comparison with those of the excited-state proton transfer (ESIPT) [26] and excimer emission [27]. It is worthwhile to note that this represents the first example of CPL-active organic conjugated system with TICT characteristics. Moreover, single crystal o-1 exhibits intense CPL with a g lum value of +0.13, which is attributed to the fine-tuning and precise control of dihedral angles of BINOL in the excited states. Substantially, the TICT process of o-carborane-based BINOL molecule is beneficial to regulate its dynamic conformations for enhancing magnetic transition dipole moments and forbidding electric transition dipole moments, thus boosting g lum values.

Results and Discussion
The synthetic routes to o-1 and o-2 are depicted in Supplementary Materials. o-1 and o-2 were synthesized in an average yield about 53% by Diels-Alder cross-coupling reaction of decaborane with (R)-2,2 ′ -diethoxy-6,6 ′ -bis(phenylethynyl)-1,1 ′ -binaphthyl and (R)-2,2 ′ -diethoxy-3,3 ′ -bis(phenylethynyl)-1,1 ′ -binaphthyl using N, N-dimethylaniline as a Lewis base. The chemical structures of o-1 and o-2 were identified by 1 H·NMR, 13 C·NMR, and 11 B·NMR spectroscopy as well as X-ray crystal data. Both are stable to H 2 O, air, and heat in solution and solid states. Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) was employed to determine the thermal stability of o-1 and o-2. As shown in Figure S1, o-1 and o-2 exhibited good thermal stability with decomposition temperatures which started at approximately 417°C and 375°C, respectively, with a weight loss of 5% under a N 2 atmosphere. Figures S2-3 demonstrated that o-1 and o-2 showed typical π − π * bands of the BINOL moieties in the range of 295 to 380 nm, devoid of effective conjugation between BINOL and the o-carborane moieties. Solvent-dependent TICT emissions were observed for o-1 and o-2, showing dual emissions in pure organic solvents [28]. With the increase of the solvent polarity, the emission bands of o-1 and o-2 exhibited noteworthy bathochromic shifts and their emission intensities decreased remarkably, indicating that the solvent polarity performed a paramount function in regulating the excited-state electronic conformation [29].
To study the chiroptical properties of o-1 and o-2, the optical behaviors in aggregated states in the H 2 O-THF system were investigated. As shown in Figure S4, the solutionstate emissions of o-1 and o-2 were hardly observed at the water fraction (f w ) less than 90% with no aggregation that occurred. When f w was up to 90%, the weak emission bands of o-1 and o-2 centered at 592 nm and 563 nm swiftly emerged, respectively. As f w was 95%, the λ em value of o-1 had an obvious blue shift by 31 nm with respect to f w of 90%, while o-2 was only slightly blue shifted by 9 nm [28]. It was clearly demonstrated that the red-shifted spectra were attributed to the lowest TICT excited states [30]. On the other hand, the selective introduction of ocarborane units onto the BINOL skeletons also exerted influence on their aggregated patterns, resulting in different aggregation-induced emission-(AIE-) active properties. In order to explore the possible expression of chirality in aggregates and to obtain more chiral conformations of the assemblies in the ground states, circular dichroism (CD) spectra of o-1 and o-2 were performed in H 2 O/THF solutions. CD bands of o-1 and o-2 displayed an almost mirror image relationship. As depicted in Figure 2 and S5, o-1 and o-2 exhibited opposite signs in the first Cotton CD band at the position of the π-π ⁎ band, suggesting that the bisignate Cotton effects came originally from the excitation couplings between obliquely oriented neighboring transition dipole moments [31]. In this regard, upon increasing the water fraction, the signal of CD has an obvious decrease and red shift, demonstrating a weak asymmetric nature of the self-assembly architecture of o-1. However, the CD signal of o-2 did not have an obvious change with the increasing water fraction in the H 2 O/THF solution. The major causes are that three-dimensional ocarborane substituents onto the BINOL skeletons lead to chirality inversion relative to BINOL. In this process, the conformation of o-2 underwent a portion of racemization. The positive CD couplet signified that o-1 had a predominantly P-chiral organization, while negative CD couplet of o-2 presented an M-chiral organization [32]. It proved that the chiral configuration of o-2 underwent a complete inversion relative to that of o-1 due to the selective introduction of three-dimensional o-carborane substituents onto the BINOL units. These results correlated well with the results from the UV spectra.
To quantitatively access the level of CPL, the degree of CPL is evaluated using the dimensionless Kuhn's anisotropy factor (g lum ) in photoexcited states. CPL signals of o-1 and o-2 were measured when the water fraction was 95% in the H 2 O/THF solution. The CPL signal is sensitive to external stimuli and also regarded as a remarkable indicator of excited molecular structures. As depicted in Figure 3, the g lum value for o-1 is +9:13 × 10 −4 at 561 nm and for o-2 is −1:81 × 10 −3 at 627 nm, when f w is up to 95%. Interestingly, o-1 and o-2 are almost mirror images, and the signs of the CPL spectra are reverse even though o-1 and o-2 have the same axially chi-ral BINOL unit. Indeed, the sign of the CPL spectra for o-1 is positive with a P-chiral organization, whereas that of o-2 is negative with a M-chiral organization. However, the detected absolute g lum value decreased by one order of magnitude of o-1 compared to that of o-2, depending on the nature of the excited structures. One reason is that the irregular aggregated   assembles are unfavorable for enhancing the g lum values, as supported by scanning electron microscopy (SEM) images ( Figure S7) [33]. It should be noted that it is readily available to record the CPL signals of o-1 and o-2 in the self-assemble states, and the detected CPL signals are mainly ascribed to the TICT emissions in the excited states. A dynamic excited molecular structure opens a way for regulating its magnetic and electric transition dipole moments, which is beneficial to boost the g lum values. This can explain why the g lum value for o-2 was larger than that of o-1 in the aggregated states.
To unravel the essence of the CPL sign reversal, the timedependent density functional theory (TD-DFT) with the CAM-B3LYP functional was carried out. CD spectra are dominated by dihedral angles of the BINOL units through the investigation of chiroptical CD signs in the fluidic solution and solid states of BINOL luminophores with the same axial chirality. However, the specific relationship between CPL activity of TICT dyes and their excited conformations has been rarely reported even in aggregated states. While the optimized excited-state (S 1 ) conformation of o-1 is characterized by a highly twisted BINOL core with a twisting angle (θ) of -54.20°, o-2 is found to be more planar, featuring a larger θ of -129.19° (Figure 4). It can be inferred that the conformation of o-2 underwent a reversion with respect to o-1 even though both compounds have the same axially chiral BINOL units [34]. The g lum value of o-2 is larger than  that of o-1 when f w is 95%, revealing that the g lum value is mainly determined by the aggregated electronic structure in the excited states. The highest occupied molecular orbital (HOMO) levels in both conformers are located almost on BINOL moieties, while the lowest unoccupied molecular orbital (LUMO) levels reside on BINOL moiety and the connected partial C-C bond in one o-carborane moiety, giving rise to a piece of direct evidence for the notable characteristic ICT behaviors. Hence, CPL caused by aggregated behaviors comes originally from the TICT states.
The emission features of o-1 and o-2 crystallines are analyzed by photophysical spectroscopy and low-temperature emission spectra. As depicted in Figure 5 [35,36]. To verify this assumption, the fluorescence spectra of o-1 and o-2 at 77 K were recorded in the crystalline states. Generally, the rotation of o-carborane is suppressed in frozen media resulting in LE emission. As shown in Figure 5(b), the new emission bands o-1 and o-2 were observed in the range of 380-480 nm with the vibrational peaks, which were attributed to the emission from the localized excited (LE) states. The other broadband was attributed to the TICT emissions at 547 nm [37], indicating that intramolecular rotations take place even in the crystalline states.  via TICT electronic transitions, originating from unidirectional movement of o-carborane moieties in the crystalline states.
As depicted in Figure S6, CD spectra of o-1 in the KBrdispersed states displayed a bisignate Cotton effect with a positive wave at around 322 nm accompanied by a pronounced wavelength at around 360 nm and a negative wave at around 279 nm, indicating that chirality signal transferred from BINOL to o-carborane units. Meanwhile, a well-resolved bisignate CD signal of o-2 was observed with a positive wave at around 310 nm accompanied by a pronounced wavelength at around 247 nm and a negative wave at around 265 nm. These results also correlated well with the results of the UV spectra. The measurements of the solid-state CPL of o-1 and o-2 were carried out. As shown in Figure 6, o-1 and o-2 in crystal powders exhibit strong CPL emissions located at 563 nm and 562 nm, and their g lum values are +0.05 and -0.01, respectively. Also, it is notable that, in single-crystalline states, the CPL emission bands of o-1 and o-2 centered at 578 nm and 556 nm, and their g lum values are +0.13 and -0.04, respectively. The CPL signs agreed with those of the CD signals at the longest wavelengths, indicating that the ground and excited states exhibited similar conformations. Thus, the chirality signals of o-1 and o-2 inherently originated from P-chiral organization and M-chiral organization, respectively. The distinct difference of g lum further confirms that o-1 may take a more twisted conformation in the excited states.
To better understand the CPL properties of o-1 and o-2, crystals were obtained from the mixed solutions of methanol and dichloromethane. Their single-crystal structures were investigated in detail, and crystallographic data are given in Table S1-2. Both o-1 and o-2 adopted a three-dimensional twisted conformational structure in orthorhombic P2 1 2 1 2 1 . The data are summarized in Table S1-2. The dihedral angles between BINOL and the C-C bonds in the ocarborane units of o-1 are +106.67°and +93.33°, respectively. The BINOL angle is -75.29°. As shown in Figures 7 and 8, no distinct π-π stacking between BINOL units was found in the crystalline packing for o-1 and o-2, which facilitated the rotation of the o-carborane cluster to induce transformations among various conformation states.  That is, the crystallization of o-1 takes a more twisted conformation than that of the aggregated states, which thus induces the TICT activity upon crystallization. The TICT states are responsible for CPL in the crystalline states, suggesting that the chirality signals transferred from BINOL to o-carborane units through space energy transfer [38]. As shown in Figure 8,    conformation of o-2 was almost not altering, leading to no alteration of the magnetic and electric transition dipole moments. Natural transition orbital (NTO) is employed to analyze a π-π * transition of the BINOL moiety and additional TICT contribution from the central BINOL donor to the peripheral o-carborane acceptor for o-1 and o-2, as shown in Figure S10 [39]. Hence, the nature of the CPL for o-1 and o-2 is the result of TICT states in the crystalline phases. Theoretically, g lum is defined as 4j mjμj cos θ/ðjmj 2 + jμj 2 Þ. Accordingly, high g lum values could only be achieved for m-allowed and μ-forbidden transitions, while low values are generally expected for m -forbidden and μ-allowed transitions. To deduce the origin of these anomalous g lum values, we performed TD-DFT analysis at the TD-TPSSTPSS/6-31G(d,p) level [40]. The magnetic and electric transition dipole moments from S 0 ⟶ S 1 state for o-1 were 0.063 and 0.068, respectively, and for o-2 were 0.144 and 0.645, respectively. Meanwhile, the two transition dipole moments from S 1 ⟶ S 0 state, m and μ, for o-1 (i.e., with an angle of 75.51°) were 0.800 and 1.002, respectively, and for o-2 (i.e., with an angle of 176.10°) were 0.153 and 1.887, respectively. These data showed that o-1 possessed an anomalously magnetic transition dipole moment in the S 1 ⟶ S 0 state. The g lum value is derived as a combination of jmj and jμj in a relationship of g lum by (jmj/jμj cos θ). Thus, unlike conventional organic molecules with negligible magnetic transition dipole moment contributions, it stands to reason that the choice of 3,3′-and 6,6′-substituted o-carborane in o-1 and o-2 exerts a great influence on the molecular packing and electronic transmission, responsible for modulating the magnetic and electric transition dipole moments. The dynamic rotational movements of o-carborane moieties may lead to a small jμj value and enhance the corresponding jmj value, arising an enhancement of the g lum value [41]. This is why o-1 manifests a larger g lum than that of o-2 in crystalline states [42]. Moreover, the choice of 3,3′-and 6,6′-substituted o-carborane in o-1 and o-2 can regulate their arrangement of dipoles in the crystalline and even resolve their electronic spin directions upon photoexcited states, which have a direct correction with their chirality organizations, as shown in Figure 1(d). This gives a direct explanation that o-1 and o-2 exhibit inverse signals.

Conclusions
To conclude, a set of CPL-active organic conjugated systems based on chiral o-carborane-binaphthyl dyads have been designed, synthesized, and systematically investigated. Both dyads, in the crystalline states, exhibited TICT emissions owing to the dynamic rotational movement of o-carborane units, which represents the first example of CPL-active organic material system with TICT characteristics. Moreover, single-crystal o-1 exhibits intense CPL with a boosting g lum value approaching +0.13, the highest value ever recorded in organic conjugated systems by far. Controlling dihedral angles in BINOL units is responsible for regulating molecular conformations, and the electron-deficient o-car-borane is beneficial to enhance the magnetic transition dipole moments and forbidding the electric transition dipole moments, thus promoting a larger g lum value. This study provides an efficient molecular engineering strategy for the rational design and development of highly efficient CPLactive materials with boosting g lum values.